Now that everyone has seen it, I will post my thoughts of Revenge of the Sith. My major problems with the movie are as follows:
1) Why can’t Artoo fly anymore?
2) So wait, you’re telling me that Obi-Wan Kenobi was there for the delivery of both Luke and Leia, but he forgot that Leia was Luke’s sister in Episode V? (He clearly knew who Leia was, as she sent him that famous “Help me, Obi-Wan Kenobi, you’re my only hope!” message that we all know and love.) There’s senile, and then there’s senile.
3) Jar-Jar Binks lived and Mace Windu died.
4) Gravity? I suppose that’s my problem with Star Wars in general. Light Sabre fights would look much cooler in zero gravity. Then we’d see all of these severed limbs floating throughout the movie.
5) Jar-Jar Binks lived and Padme Amidala died.
6) The “romantic” dialogue. Shakespeare Lucas ain’t, and Romeo and Juliet this wasn’t. The biggest reason this was a problem for me is that Skywalker’s betrayal of the Jedi and turning to the Dark Side is supposed to be driven by his forbidden love for her. An example would be:
Anakin: You’re so beautiful
Padme: It’s only because I’m so in love.
Anakin: No, its because I’m so in love with you.
Padme: So your love blinds you then?
Anakin: That’s not what I meant.
Padme: No, probably not.
So begins the destruction of the Jedi order. And my intelligence.
7) While Mace Windu indeed did not “go out like some punk” as per Mr. Jackson’s request, every other Jedi did. SPOILER: The lightsaber fight put up by the three Jedi with Windu as he tried to arrest Palpatine was pitiful at best, and with the exception of perhaps Master Voss, all of the others were dealt with in a way that is pretty pathetic if you consider that they are supposed to be in tune with the Force so that they can avoid getting shot in the back by a stormtrooper. I can only assume that they got their Jedi skills from the same place that teaches the Imperial forces how to shoot people.
The point at which Obi-Wan declares that “only the Sith deal in absolutes”, [fantasy] at which point the irony police come in and arrest him for denouncing absolute statements using an absolute statement. [/fantasy]
9) Jar-Jar Binks lived and Count Dooku died.
10) That had to have been the most ridiculous opening crawl of all six movies.
There was also some pretty good acting. Ewan McGregor and Ian McDiarmid both did wonderful jobs. If what McGregor did wasn’t Oscar caliber, then it was pretty close to it. I really loved the scene at the end where he laments Vader’s crossing over to the Dark Side. Natalie Portman, sadly, got short changed, since the only lines she got to say, for the most part, were Lucas’ dreadful imaginings of what romantic dialouge is. She did do the best she could with what she had, however, and was rewarded with one of the best lines in the whole movie: “So this is how liberty dies. With thunderous applause.” Any faults in her character development I blame on the script, and not the actor. Hayden Christensen, however, has no such excuse. Let us all be thankful that by the end of it all he was covered from head to toe with Vaderwear, and no longer had any lines of his own (James Earl Jones came back for the voice of Vader.)
When the emperor said to Anakin “Good is a point of view, Anakin. And the Jedi point of view is not the only valid one.” the first thing that came to my mind was Pope Benedict’s line about the “dictatorship of relativism.” That’s probably about as literal an example of that as you are going to get this side of Paradise. Also the follow up line to that:
Obi-Wan: Anakin, Chancellor Palpatine is evil.
Vader: Well from my point of view, the Jedi are evil.
Obi-Wan: Then you’re lost!
Overall, a pretty entertaining flick. About two and a half hours in length, you may want to make a run to the bathroom either before the movie starts, or whenever a scene occurs where Anakin is getting all googley-eyed with Padme.